
JudyPie Menu
Update Pick-Up Date & Time for Pies to Become Available!

Valentines Day Menu
Share your love with delicious treats from JudyPie
Raspberry Rose 10% off for Valentines!
Valentines Day is the perfect time of year to bring Raspberry Rose to the daily menu! Celebrate your valentine with 10% some red raspberry pie. Made with a cream cheese filling, raspberry puree inside a graham cracker crust topped with whipped cream.
10"
$45
6"
$16

Heart Cake - 6 Inch
Looking to sprinkle a little love into your celebrations? Look no further than our delightful Heart Cake that can be either Vanilla or Red Velvet. It can be decorated with XOXO or Be Mine for that extra touch of sweetness! Imagine the smiles and joy as your loved ones indulge in this decadent treat, perfectly crafted to reflect your unique love story.
27.99
Cake Flavor
Vanilla
Red Velvet

Strawberry Roll
The Strawberry Roll Cake is truly a delightful way to capture anyone's heart, featuring a luscious blend of fresh, juicy strawberries enveloped in a cloud of sweet whipped cream. This exquisite dessert not only embodies the essence of homemade goodness that Judy Pie is renowned for but also serves as a perfect centerpiece for creating cherished memories with loved ones. Treat yourself and those you care about to this delectable indulgence, and don't miss the chance to order online easily and quickly to ensure you get this delightful cake while it lasts!
32.99

Puppy Cake
Indulge in the delightful joy of the Red Velvet Puppy Cake and watch as it casts a spell of happiness over your beloved four-legged friend! This charming cake tantalizes your pup's taste buds with its rich, velvety texture that they simply can't resist. Plus, you have the option to personalize it. Each cake is lovingly crafted with only pup-approved ingredients that ensure safety and flavor! Be sure to send a picture with your pup eating their Valentine cake, and a chance to win a prize. The puppy cake is made with rice flour, cane sugar, beet powder, baking powder, one egg, oil, and water.
29.95


Daily Pie Menu
24-HOUR TURNAROUND
Apple Crumble Pie
Made with plump Granny Smith apples topped with a sweet apple crumble. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
10"
$49.50
6"
$18.50
4" (Includes one dozen)
$75

Banana Pudding Pie
Traditional banana pudding pie with a vanilla wafer crust. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
10"
$49.50
6"
$18.50
4" (Includes one dozen)
$75

Cherry Pie
Judy's cherry pie is made with red plump tart cherries and has a yummy light filling. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
10"
$49.50
6"
$18.50
4" (Includes one dozen)
$75

Cherry Merlot Pie
4 lbs of tart delicious red cherries. Our Chef has come up with a wonderful twist by infusing the cherries with a Merlot. No jellie in our pies!
10"
$49.50
6"
$18.50
4" (Includes one dozen)
$75

Chocolate Cream Pie
Made with semi-sweet creamy chocolate topped with whipped cream and chocolate shavings with a traditional crust. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
10"
$49.50
6"
$18.50
4" (Includes one dozen)
$75

Coconut Cream Pie
50 yr old family recipe made with coconut and a traditional flaky crust. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
10"
$49.50
6"
$18.50
4" (Include one dozen)
$75
My New Option
Whipped Cream
Meringue (ONLY 10")

Creme Brûlée Pie
Irresistible Creme Brûlée Pie! This crowd-pleasing dessert perfectly imitates the velvety custard and caramelized sugar shell.
10"
$49.50
6"
$18.50
4" (Includes one dozen)
$75

Dirty Judy
Dense, Rich, Chocolate! Everything good about the world in a pie! It’s got the looks of a disaster, but the taste of a gourmet meal!
10"
$49.50
6"
$18.50
4" (Includes one dozen)
$75

Key Lime Pie
Made with real Key limes inside a delicious graham cracker crust. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
10"
$49.50
6"
$18.50
4" (Includes one dozen)
$75

Memphis Mafia Pie
Graham cracker crust with several layers of chocolate ganache, peanut butter, banana, peanuts, Reese's pieces, chocolate, caramel, whipped cream, and bacon. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
10"
$49.50
6"
$18.50
4" (Includes one dozen)
$75

Punky Pumpkin Pie
Traditional Pumpkin Pie with a flaky crust.
10"
$49.50

Rhoda's Pecan Pie
Traditional nutty pecan pie with a flaky crust. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM.
10"
$49.50
6"
$18.50
4" (Includes one dozen)
$75

Rhoda's Chocolate Pecan Pie
Traditional Pecan pie with chunks of chocolate and a flaky crust. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
10"
$49.50
6"
$18.50
4" (Includes one dozen)
$75

Rhoda's Bourbon Pecan Pie
Traditional nutty pecan pie with a flaky crust. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
10"
$49.50
6"
$18.50
4" (Includes one dozen)
$75

Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
Sweet strawberries married with a sour rhubarb and a traditional crust. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
10"
$49.50
6"
$18.50
4" (Includes one dozen)
$75


3 Day Turnaround Pies
3-DAY TURNAROUND
Red Velvet Pie
A red velvet cake with a short bread crust and traditional cream cheese frosting. Pick-Up Info: 3-day turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
10"
$49.50

German Chocolate
Made with layers of dense chocolate topped with coconut and a caramel inside a shortbread crust. Pick-Up Info: 3 day turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
10"
$49.50

Lemon Chess
A rich lemony, buttery-filling pie, passed down from my great Grandmother. It was said that she would create the pie, and the men would gather and play chess.
10"
$49.50

Adohree-A-Doodle Pie
Judy's favorite pie is made with Adohree's secret Snickerdoodle recipe, and is named after her daughter, Adohree. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
10"
$49.50

Blueberry Ginger
Made with fresh blueberries and ginger Pick up Info: 3-day turnaround with pick up available after 11 AM
10"
$49.50

Maple Bourbon Peach
10"
$49.50

Buttermilk Pie
Just a sweet creamy naked pie that we guarantee tastes just like your Grandmother's. Shipped in a lovely tin can. Include recipients name, & address and we will do the rest. Enclosure card included. Please note address on special instructions. Price includes shipping. Discounts available for 50 or more.
10"
$49.50

Raspberry Rose
Made with a cream cheese filling, raspberry puree inside a graham cracker crust topped with whipped cream. Pick-Up Info: 3-day turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
10"
$49.50
6"
$18.50
4" (Includes one dozen)
$75

Pumpkin Roll
Pick-Up Info: 24 hours turnaround with pick-up available after 12 PM.
32.99


Keto, GF, & Vegan Cheesecake Menu
24 hour notice for Gluten Free Cheesecake. *All other GF - 3 weeks
10" Pecan Pie
Rich Pecan pie, without the use of corn syrup. Gluten-Free, Dairy-Free, Soy-Free, & Peanut-Free.
59.99

Gluten Free Whole Reese's Cheesecake
Rich and delicious 10 inch Gluten Free Reese's Cheesecake. Melts in your mouth.
69.99

Gluten Free Whole NY Cheesecake
Introducing our newest addition to our menu, the gluten-free cheesecake. Made with a dense and creamy filling using real cream cheese, this classic dessert is the perfect way to end any meal. Our gluten-free option ensures that everyone can enjoy a delicious dessert without compromising their dietary needs. Share a slice with someone who is gluten-free and delight in the rich and satisfying taste of our cheesecake. Treat yourself to a guilt-free indulgence today.
69.99

Gluten Free Whole Key Lime Cheesecake
Our creamy cheesecake married key limes, and created a sweet dessert with just the right amount of tang. Made with the freshest ingredients, our Gluten Free Key Lime cheesecake features a creamy filling that's rich in flavor and silky smooth in texture. Enjoy every bite as a mouth-watering experience, that will have you coming back for more. Share with your gluten free friends, they will love you.
69.99


Cake Menu
TURNAROUND VARIES DEPENDING ON THE CAKE! PLEASE READ THE CAKE DESCRIPTION FOR MORE INFO!
German Chocolate Cake
Made from scratch, our take on the classic german chocolate cake topped with coconut and pecans. Pick-Up Info: 2 day turnaround with pick-up available after 12 PM Serves 8-10. ** Writing on cake: add it to the order notes section at checkout.
65
My New Option
Writing on Cake
$5
Carrot Cake
All fresh ingredients and made from scratch. Not only does it taste delicious, but is equally beautiful! Serves 8-10. Pick-Up Info: 2 day turnaround with pick-up available after 12 PM ** Writing on cake: add it to the order notes section at checkout.
65
My New Option
Writing on Cake
$5
Vanilla Bean Cheesecake
Delicious, dense cheesecake-flavored cake topped with rich icing and flakes. Pick-Up Info: 3 day turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
84

Chocolate Pudding Cake
Delicious, dense chocolate cake topped with rich icing and chocolate curls. Pick-Up Info: 3 day turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
84

Custom Dog Cakes
Celebrate your pup's birthday with a yummy cake! Please include what you would like written on your cake and what color in the notes section on the checkout page.
35
Flavor
Red Velvet
Pumpkin Spice
Birthday Cake

Red Velvet Cake
Made from scratch, this southern classic and Ophrah's favorite is smooth velvet with a mild chocolate flavor. Serves 8-10. Pick-Up Info: 72 hours turnaround with pick-up available after 12 PM ** Writing on cake: add it to the order notes section at checkout.
65
My New Option
Writing on Cake
$5
Tiramisu
Made of sponge cake dipped in coffee, layered with a whipped mixture of eggs, sugar and mascarpone and flavored with cocoa. Pick-Up Info: 3 day turnaround with pick-up available after 12 PM Serves 8-10. ** Writing on cake: add it to the order notes section at checkout.
75
My New Option
Writing on Cake
$5

Cookies, Hand Pies, & More Menu
24-HOUR TURNAROUND
Hand Pies | Half a Dozen
Half a dozen sweet hand pies filled with flavors like Apple, Cherry, Lemon Raspberry, or Peach. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
49.50
Flavors
Apple
Cherry
Lemon Raspberry

Stickie Buns | Half a Dozen
Half a dozen delicious fluffy stickie buns. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM.
39

Cookies | Half a Dozen
Half a dozen of delicious in-house-made cookies. Flavors include Blueberry Lemon, Skillet, Chocolate Chunk, M&M, Peanut Butter, or Snickerdoodle. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
25
Flavors
Snickerdoodle
M&M
Peanut Butter

Cinnamon Rolls | Half a Dozen
Half a dozen delicious fluffy cinnamon rolls. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM.
35.94

Strawberry Whipped Cream Roll
Pick-Up Info: 2-day turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM.
32.99
