Homemade Pies
orders on our daily menu can be ordered today and picked up next day; with the exception of Sunday. Please set a pick up date for your order from the drop down menu. If drop down menu does not work, please make a note of the day you want to pick up your pie. Thank you and keep it sweet.
Pie It Forward
This is the spot where you package your love. Order as much or as little as you like. Make it anonymous or not, for a special event or just because, for someone you know, or not...the choice is yours.
1 Slice of Pie It Forward
Pie it forward a sweet slice of pie to anyone you know. Order online and in special instructions, submit the recipients name, email address, and the message you wish to include. We will take care of the rest. We will send a Evite letting your person know there is a sweet slice of pie waiting for them at JudyPie. Be anonymous or let them know who has Pie Forwarded them sweetness. Call for questions.
8
Maple Bourbon Peach 10"
A uniting of sweet peaches, a dash of bourbon and a maple syrup. So delicious heated with ice cream.
My New Choice
45
Chocolate Cream Pie
Creamy old fashioned chocolate (Rhoda's recipe, of course) in a light and tender crust with whipped cream and chocolate curls.
45
Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
Sweet meets sour, and they marry! I have to admit, not Rhoda's recipe. We are Texans! Pie will be Strawberry Rhubarb unless you specify Strawberry only.
45
Rhoda's Pecan Pie
Crisp and nutty pecans, not too sweet filling and a ever so light Rhoda crust. You will swear you are eating your Grandmother's Pecan Pie. We ship this pie all over the world.
45
Tart & Sweet Cherry Pie
In our 10" pie, 3 Pounds of Tart Cherries in a tender buttery crust. It's sure to touch your heart and just perfect for your taste buds.
45
Banana Pudding Pie
Just like Nanny use to make with vanilla wafers, banana's and whipped cream in a vanilla wafer crust.
45
Apple Crumble Pie
Same filling as our traditional apple, but with a crumble topping.
45
Memphis Mafia
Our delicious Peanut Butter Truffle pie married our Banana Pudding Pie, and we decided that was the perfect marriage for you holiday table. Try some now. All that is missing is Elvis. The pie starts with a Graham cracker crust, a layer of banana's with a chocolate ganache ladled on top. A creamy peanut butter on top of that, and of course more chocolate, peanuts and Reese's pieces with crumbled "BACON" on top.
45
Coconut Cream Pie
Flaky tender Rhoda Crust, filled with coconut custard and just the right amount of fresh coconut. With sweet whipped cream topping.
45
Chocolate Pudding Cake
Decadent chocolate truffle and cake with love in every bite. Not gluten free. Serves 12.
75.00
German Chocolate Pie
Just like Grandma's Cake, only in a light Shortbread Crust with loaded with, pecans and coconut. Shipped in a lovely tin can. Include recipients name, & address and we will do the rest. Enclosure card included. Please note address on special instructions. Price includes shipping. Discounts available for 50 or more.
45.00
Apple Crumble
We use 3 lbs. Granny Smith apples in our apple pie. You can order with a lattice crust or a light cinnamon crumble topping.
45.00