JudyPie Menu
Update Pick-Up Date & Time for Pies to Become Available!
Thanksgiving Menu
Thanksgiving Pie Menu for PICK-UP on November 24th, 25th and 26th ONLY. Savory pies will be FROZEN and baking directions will be provided.
6" Thanksgiving Pre-Order | Order before Nov 9th
The special includes two 6-inch Thanksgiving pre-order pies. Your choice of any two Thanksgiving pre-order pies. Thanksgiving pre-order pies include Apple Crumble, Rhoda's Pecan Pie, Rhoda's Chocolate Pecan Pie, Rhoda's Bourbon Pecan Pie, Rhoda's Chocolate Bourbon Pecan Pie, Cherry, Cherry Merlot, Chocolate Cream, Key Lime, Strawberry Rhubarb, Punky Pumpkin, Shepherds Pie, and Chicken Pot Pie. * Pick-Up Available on Monday 24th, Tuesday 25th, and Wednesday 26th only | The price is for 2 pies. | Pre-Order Cutoff Date: November 9th | No Refunds On Pre-Ordered Pies
$33
Pie #2
Apple Crumble
Cherry
Cherry Merlot
10" Pie
10" Pies available for Thanksgiving week pick up! November 24th, 25th & 26th
$49.50
Pie Flavor
Apple Crumble
Cherry
Cherry Merlot
6" Pie
6" Pies available for Thanksgiving week pick up! November 24th, 25th & 26th
$18.50
Pie Flavor
Apple Crumble
Cherry
Cherry Merlot
Pumpkin Roll
$32.99
Pick up Date
Nov 24th
Nov 25th
Nov 26th
Daily Pie Menu
24-HOUR TURNAROUND
Banana Pudding Pie
Traditional banana pudding pie with a vanilla wafer crust. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
10"
$49.50
6"
$18.50
4" (Includes one dozen)
$75
Cherry Pie
Judy's cherry pie is made with red plump tart cherries and has a yummy light filling. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
10"
$49.50
6"
$18.50
4" (Includes one dozen)
$75
Cherry Merlot Pie
Judy's cherry pie is made with red plump tart cherries and a light filling with hints of merlot. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
10"
$49.50
6"
$18.50
4" (Includes one dozen)
$75
Coconut Cream Pie
50 yr old family recipe made with coconut and a traditional flaky crust. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
10"
$49.50
6"
$18.50
4" (Include one dozen)
$75
My New Option
Whipped Cream
Meringue (ONLY 10")
Creme Brûlée Pie
Irresistible Creme Brûlée Pie! This crowd-pleasing dessert perfectly imitates the velvety custard and caramelized sugar shell.
10"
$49.50
6"
$18.50
4" (Includes one dozen)
$75
Memphis Mafia Pie
Graham cracker crust with several layers of chocolate ganache, peanut butter, banana, peanuts, Reese's pieces, chocolate, caramel, whipped cream, and bacon. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
10"
$49.50
6"
$18.50
4" (Includes one dozen)
$75
Rhoda's Pecan Pie
Traditional nutty pecan pie with a flaky crust. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM.
10"
$49.50
6"
$18.50
4" (Includes one dozen)
$75
Rhoda's Bourbon Pecan Pie
Traditional nutty pecan pie with a flaky crust. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
10"
$49.50
6"
$18.50
4" (Includes one dozen)
$75
Dirty Judy
Dense, Rich, Chocolate! Everything good about the world in a pie! It’s got the looks of a disaster, but the taste of a gourmet meal!
10"
$49.50
6"
$18.50
4" (Includes one dozen)
$75
Apple Lattice
Our traditional apple filling with a golden lattice top
10"
$49.50
Punky Pumpkin Pie
Traditional Pumpkin Pie with a flaky crust.
10"
$49.50
Cookies, Hand Pies, & More Menu
24-HOUR TURNAROUND
Hand Pies | Half a Dozen
Half a dozen sweet hand pies filled with flavors like Apple, Cherry, Lemon Raspberry, or Peach. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
$49.50
Flavors
Apple
Cherry
Lemon Raspberry
Cookies | Half a Dozen
Half a dozen of delicious in-house-made cookies. Flavors include Blueberry Lemon, Skillet, Chocolate Chunk, M&M, Peanut Butter, Snickerdoodle, or Sugar. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
$25
Flavors
Snickerdoodle
M&M
Peanut Butter
Strawberry Whipped Cream Roll
Pick-Up Info: 2-day turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM.
$32.99
